
Mikhail Metzel / AP
Members of pro-Kremlin youth movements beat drums at Triumphal Square in Moscow on Tuesday.
MOSCOW -- The election official had a problem. Workers at his polling station had been stuffing ballot boxes with votes for Vladimir Putin's party all day, he says, but when the votes were counted United Russia still didn't have enough.
So he huddled with the election commission he chaired at the Moscow precinct. The decision: Putin's party would get the desired 65 percent. One member objected, but relented when the others tossed his Communist Party a few dozen votes.
The commission chairman spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity for fear of losing his job. He also said he could be punished for disobeying orders to report any contact with foreign observers or journalists to the FSB, the successor to the Soviet-era KGB.
His account closely matches reports by independent observers of rampant vote-rigging during Sunday's election, in which United Russia maintained its majority in parliament. Amateur videos posted on the Internet also appeared to show falsified ballots spilling out of boxes at polling stations.
Officially, United Russia got roughly 50 percent of the vote, a significant drop from the 64 percent the party won in the last election. But the reports of fraud indicate it may have lost even more support than those results suggest. Central Election Commission officials said they have received no reports of serious violations but would investigate any formal complaints.
This election was emerging as a watershed moment in a country where people have long seemed inured to vote manipulation, both before and after the fall of the Soviet Union. The fraud allegations have set off protests in the street and stirred broader public indignation, suggesting that the political system Putin built to solidify his control has begun to crack just three months ahead of a vote on his return to the presidency. The lackluster opposition has suddenly been energized.
Anger over the election drew more than 5,000 people Monday night, in one of the biggest anti-Putin protests in years. Police detained about 300 protesters to prevent them from marching to the Central Elections Commission near the Kremlin. New protests on Tuesday night were thwarted by police, who were out in force after having been taken by surprise the night before.
Amateur videos claiming to show the vote being rigged have spread via social media networks, including one in which the chairman of an election commission is filling out a stack of ballots. The clip attracted so much attention that city election officials were forced to acknowledge that the chairman had been caught falsifying the vote and could face charges.
The commission chairman who spoke to the AP said that representatives of Russia's four main parties got together before the election to negotiate how many votes each would get in district precincts. United Russia initially wanted 68 to 70 percent, but conceded that was too high and settled for around 65.
On voting day, the chairman said, election workers quietly slipped ballots into the boxes, as many as 50 at a time, being careful to keep the papers from rustling and attracting the attention of observers.
He said workers were trained on how to stuff ballots, each a thin sheet roughly the size of standard letter paper. He demonstrated how a stack of up to 30 or even 50 ballots could be folded in half, hidden inside a jacket and slipped into the ballot box without making any noise.
The chairman said there was a limit to the amount of ballot stuffing his commission could do. So district election officials took a few hundred of the precincts ballot, filled them out for United Russia and gave them to migrant men not on the precinct's rolls. Fake voter lists were substituted for the real ones.
During a tour of the polling station, the commission chairman pointed to a spot along the far wall where he had put chairs for observers. He said one observer was particularly zealous, never leaving the room during the 12-hour voting period, even to use the toilet.
The chairman said he got the police to evict the observer 10 minutes before the polls closed, too late for a replacement to be sent. Election monitoring groups and political parties have complained that their observers were barred from many polling places.
When the votes were counted, United Russia got only about 50 percent, even with all the extra ballots; the chairman said its real support had been about 25 percent. Turnout also was low, another setback for the Putin camp.
But when the chairman reported the 50 percent result to the district election commission, he said, he was told to make it 65 percent in the official report, which needed to be signed by all 15 members of the commission. Turnout was also to be inflated.
Most of the commission members willingly went along with the change, he said, and the one holdout was appeased when a few dozen votes were taken from smaller parties and given to the Communists.
The director of Golos, an independent election watchdog, said chairmen of election commissions at polling stations are at the center of efforts to rig the vote and routinely come under heavy pressure.
"Most of the violations we see happen at the local level," Liliya Shibanova said.
Golos says many violations involved busing people with absentee ballots to multiple polling stations so they can vote, a system called "cruise" or "carousel" voting.
Putin, who served as president from 2000 to 2008 and then moved into the prime minister's office because of presidential term limits, is hoping to return to the presidency after the March election. He had been counting on a strong show of popular support for United Russia in the parliamentary election to add legitimacy to his campaign.
He has appeared shaken by the election results and by the overall lack of enthusiasm over his decision to reclaim the presidency from Dmitry Medvedev.
Many Russians are growing weary of his leadership, and of the pervasive corruption and great social inequality it has fostered.
Still, there is little doubt that Putin will win the presidential election. He remains more popular than his party and will likely face only tepid opposition, given his control over who is allowed to run.
Putin seems to realize that he needs to respond to the discontent, but gave no sign Tuesday that he knows how.
"As for the question of what exactly is worrying people and why they don't vote for United Russia but vote for other parties, of course we need to think about this," he said. "We need to analyze these problems and formulate further suggestions on solving them."
More news and features from msnbc.com:


The Machine is alive and well in Russia. Shades of NY and Chicago.
MSNBC news article 1 January 2012: Holder admits he rigged voting booths.
can you find that source or are you playing Rush Limbaugh?
I no longer trust the vote anywhere.
iAre you sure you do not mean Florida and Ohio? Karl Rowe?
Yeah it was Ohio that closed the vote count to observers and shut down the building due to "Homeland Security". America's voting has not been much better.
Great comment from John McCain: "Dear Vlad, the Arab spring is coming to a place near you!" but has he realized that it already has come to a place near him, too?
I can't wait for Arab Spring to come near US Congress, corruption is ruining our country.
typical politician.
I think they should of looked under her two pup tents on her chests... Nawh she didn't have anything anyone really wanted to see unless the crazy "B" had a bomb or weapon.. Give it a break.
Aussies usually have their stuff together better than this ... must be watching too much American News
Heya Davy......WRONG THREAD.
You are only about 6,500 miles away.
Dave,
I don't think anybody knows what the hell you are talking about.
Are you having a conversation with your "friends" in your head again?
Russia, have you forgotten the Nazi's so soon?
These are the tactics of the fascists. Lie, cheat, steal. Anything to prevent the will of the people from being done.
Government and business have contrived to steal your elections.
Are you going to stand for this?
.
Sounds like the Obama Chicago campaign headquarters.
Lets look at things:
Osama bin Laden dead: CHECK
Troops out of Iraq: CHECK
Halliburton under investigation: CHECK
Unemployment going down: CHECK
Anything the Democrats want to accomplish being blocked by Republicans: CHECK
Republicans fighting amoungst themselves to figure out who is better: CHECK
Kadafi dead and Libya free: CHECK
Look in the mirror and say "McCain and Palin would have done better!" and you are lying to yourself!!!
Let's look at things:
Osama Bin Laden Dead: Been dead for 10 years, Died of Lung Complications.
Troops out of Iraq: good job Obama
Haliburton Under Investigation: AFTER THEY GOT AWAY WITHT HE BP OIL FIASCO
Unemployment going down: By .4 percent, is only a seasonal change
Gaddafi Dead and Libya handed over to the Al-Queda: CHECK
You must write for Limbaugh!
UnitedStates1776 - Russia doesn't need to remember the Nazis. They had Stalin.
United State -- It sounds like you're talking about our politicians. If I look at the bunch that's in Congress right now and the republican presidential candidates, it looks like we're standing for this alright.
Ido
Obama has shown more honesty and character than any Republican living
Poor Russia - They didn't do Communism well and apparently that can't get democracy right either. Come to think of it their monarchy screwed things up as well.
I managed to get down this far and I still cannot believe any of you cant see that Russia has been doing this for decades with their phony elections.
abouth russia evertimemain event happins all country turns eac other that is scare democracy i am realy worried have friend resles all the time should we keep or shut im out
The Rooskis are Whacked...and in more ways than you can count.
I see what you did thar.
Will be interesting to see how much this poisons Putin's second time as president.
How do you say "We are the 99%" in russian?
Мы девяносто девять процентов
K. Kammeyer I'm impressed......
Pass the vodka, I'll drink to that!
I wonder if this happens in America?
Absolutley, just ask Bush, Or ACORN.
I also cannot believe ther are people who still believe the lies about Acorn even with all the proof otherwise.
it doesn't matter, we know both sides are doing it.
Power is more intoxicating than any drug in the world. Look at the US Congress for examples with CEO's and Board of Directors a close 2nd.
What a joke of a country. The Russian people can do better.
So, they pulled a Rachel Berry...
If you dont study history and react, history will repeat itself.
Seems we did not need to interfere in Mr. Putin's election. Next question is will he be smart enough to set up another puppet president and stay behind the scenes.
And this President will be Z'uganov or Zhirinovskij?
They were better off when they had Communism. At least they knew where they stood then.
Putin / Obama one in the same.
They should just buy Diebold voting machines and avoid all this nastiness. Electronic voting machine with no paper trail and no rights to audit software, who's gonna know if you've rigged it?
Good idea. You are a job creator
Justredd:
Putin / Obama one in the same.
Really? LOL, come on man... troll much?
Instead of confessing a "Russian election" was rigged, it would be a lot more interesting--nay astounding--if someone over there would actually claim that "Yes, I was there! I saw everything! It was a clean, honest election! And not a single fraudulent vote!" And then, of course, produce the evidence it actually had been an honest one!
The point is, of course, so what if the election was fraudulent: when has Russian politics ever been (or will it ever be in the future) anything else?!!
Maybe we need to teach Russia how to run a government with fair elections and no corruption? Ha Ha Ha Ha
Hillary's comments on the Russian elections:
While not really being certain on Hilary's reason to bring the Russian election scandal up I do support the fact that if it's true this needs to be corrected. Our world needs to get back on track by standing together for all the right reasons, we American's have our Constitution that we should stand together for. Russia or any other country shouldn't have to fear or feel threatened by any other country. The future of life on our planet is dependant on all the people that live in it. We need to understand that all our petty differences must end. We need to agree that each country should have their own economy as well as their personal rights that they feel is good for them and the world should stand together to protect all other countries (peoples rights) from being controlled from those with personal gain whether from within or outside of their country.
We're in a world where our resources as well as our thought processes have to deal with the truth, we are destroying everything that supports a better life as well as life itself. The only way to understand is to learn more about what's really going on rather then make decisions on what we're told. To be fair we need to be humanitarians and not financial controllers. No matter what part of the world we people live in we want to have a happy and full life, opportunities to strive for a better lifestyle as well as a ceiling so we don't fall into being to extreme in our endeavors. Balance using humanity is a key ingredient for most anything in life to be for the better with consistancy, always while moving forward when so many lives are involved.
All that is going on today in our world is slowly destroying what our future needs to survive. To add a kicker into our dilemma there are those in control of the worlds economy that also want the people on our planet to move into this future of doom unhappy, depressed, hopeless and a continued growth in apathy. Well this is the first time in my life that I've seen an opportunity for the world to stand together for all the right reasons, not to find fault on why we're here but to work towards making all that's wrong and make it right for all of us. With all the truth that the planet shares moving forward, that truth will grow into trust. Trust in our world has been missing for too many years.
Lets not fight amongst each other any more, the very few that up to now had a blanket of world control is not hard to find, they are at the end of the money chain. If we countries of the world work together to get each of our economies back we could then through World Peace work together bringing the future of a better life for all our planet
World Peace Through Humanity
where is rushdie when you need him?